.
Feedback

Question: Does Playing Football Endanger Youths?

Research into brain injuries suggest that concussions in football and repeated blows to the head can impair even young athletes. Would you rethink letting your children play football?

The suicide last week of former National Football League star Junior Seau has sparked another round of debate about how dangerous football might really be.

There's plenty of research to suggest that the hazards of football through head injuries - potentially long term damage - is not just reserved for pro players, but has become a major concern for high school athletes as well.

The Centers for Disease Controls estimate that there are between 1.6 million and 3.8 million sports-related concussions every year, and the centers conclude that they are at an "epidemic level."

On top of that, studies suggest for scholastic athletes, football creates the most potentially harmful hits to the head, and concussions in high-school football go vastly under reported.

Much of the research up until now has focused on concussions. Studies show that athletes with two or more traumatic brain injuries in their high school career demonstrate statistically significant lower grade-point averages.

Some of the new research on the study of brain injuries at Purdue University indicates that repeated blows to the head of much less force than a concussion can also create an impairment.

So, it leads to the question. What do you think about these new studies? Has any of it made you rethink whether you'd let your children play football in high school or college? As a student athlete, do you worry about the dangers?

Does it make you rethink your enjoyment of college football Saturdays or pro football Sundays?

Want to share an opinion with us? You can. Join the conversation on Facebook or leave us comment below. You can also vote in our poll.

Dunwoody Dad May 8, 2012 at 06:48 pm
Having personally played football for 13 years (Elementary School through College) and can honestly say I was injured once. Head injuries can happen in any sport at any time. (heading a soccer ball anyone? Baseball to the head?) While football is in the limelight right now, any sport or activity can be dangerous. If you play the game correctly and don't lead with your head or put your head down like any good coach would promote you'll be fine.
Parents, one way to tell if your son/daughter is playing football correctly, check their helmets, if they have too many scratches or paint marks they're not playing correctly and they need to learn to keep their head UP.
Jason Massad (Editor) May 9, 2012 at 11:48 am
Dunwoody Dad. Glad to have someone share who has played the sport, and at a high level.
I just want to point you to the link in the story about Purdue University research. The article describes researchers who basically stumbled upon a finding that repeated, moderate level hits to the head were changing neurological function in high-school football players. To me, that's significant in this whole debate. I know of no other high-school sport where you are hit in the head with that kind of force at that frequency - with our without protection - as a normal part of the game. The fact that impairment can happen prior to a concussion, according to some research, seems to go against the grain of the conventional wisdom that you only have to worry about damage if you have had a couple of concussions.
Jim Murphy May 9, 2012 at 02:41 pm
Unfortunately, I am a beat up old football player (played for Bobby Dodd) and I am on the opposite side of this debate. The injuries really depend on the position that you play. Being an interior lineman I hit or was hit multiple times EVERY play and suffered the following: 3 concussions (rope suspended helmets back in the 1960's), abdural hemotoma (with one concussion), dislocated right shoulder, cracked rib pushed into and bruised a kidney (internal bleeding and impossible to breathe), two front teeth knocked out (with mouthguard on), right knee dislocated so many times that I had a knee operation and finally a cracked left ankle; ironically, I never broke my nose. In the last few years, I have had the following replaced - left hip and right knee (the bad one), the next one to be replaced is the right hip. My orthopedist and my pain specialist say that football is a "meat grinder" that provides them many patients for many years. I tell anyone who asks to NEVER EVER play football and that I am prima facie evidence for this position. IF I could live my life over again I would have been a competitive swimmer until college and have a great lean body with NO injuries. SWIMMING is the best muscle developing sport for your ENTIRE body and the only risk is from wearing out joints from TOO much swimming.
Maxed out on Tramadol, Jim
Peter Yost May 10, 2012 at 03:34 pm
This is kind of a pointless "debate". Of course football endangers athletes at all levels. It's probably more dangerous than other sports with the possible exception of boxing and rugby. That's not really the point though.
The questions really should be, "is it worth the risk?" and "what can be done to reduce the risk while playing?" These are best answered by the player/parents of participants and by the equipment manufacturers. I wonder if injuries are trending up or down over the past 40 years as equipment has been getting more sophisticated. Clearly, there have been a lot of improvements to the gear that's used on the field for the sake of safety. A lot of rules have been changed too. Has any of that helped? Hopefully, we're not finished with these improvements and better equipment and rules are on there way to help reduce the risk of injury so young men can continue to enjoy the sport with lower risk.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Dunwoody Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Atlanta Glamdoll June 15, 2013 at 08:17 pm
The 'Cedar Grilled Lemon Dill Salmon' recipe sounds delish! Bookmarked this one! I make a similarRead More sauce for salmon using dill, parsley, a bit of rosemary (if handy), mayo (instead of the mustard), and a dash of sugar to sweeten things... gonna have to give this one a try.